WHITE PLAINS, N.Y. -- A newly published study by Nexant, Inc. -- "Liquid Biofuels: Substituting for Petroleum" -- looks at current, emerging, and potential future technologies to produce biogasoline and biodiesel, considering all key elements of the value chain, including agricultural, logistical, and processing.



Emphasizing technoeconomic modeling, the study details development trends around the world and analyzes key policy drivers, including rural development, energy independence, and reduced carbon footprint, and considers a full range of technical, feedstock, and alternative biofuel product options.



The study concludes that fatty acid methyl ester biodiesel will probably be a transition technology, capable of substituting for only a small fraction of global diesel demand. However, as a biodegradable, low-toxicity product, it will likely hold market share far into the future.



Bioethanol from grains and sugar, though an excellent high-octane gasoline blendstock, has many practical problems and is also likely to be transitional over the long term.



Nexant projects that the next phase of development is likely to be ethanol made by fermentation of sugars obtained through biomass hydrolysis. Nexant also concludes that, perhaps sooner than some may believe, integrated thermochemical platforms will take the lead in producing both gasoline and diesel range biofuels (biomass-to-liquids (BTL), similar to coal-to-liquids and gas-to-liquids), most likely in conjunction with electric power and chemicals. This alternative should be -- and probably will be -- pursued contemporaneously with developing biomass-based ethanol.



Regardless of which substrate is used to produce it, ethanol will eventually need to be dehydrated to hydrocarbon gasoline fractions that are more compatible with the existing fuel distribution and vehicle infrastructure.



In adopting ethanol dehydration, higher alcohols, and biofuels from syngas, society will make tradeoffs between two options: (1) the current renewable, sustainable biofuels that are biodegradable and have low toxicity, but have limited supply potential, and (2) other biofuels that are equally renewable and have small carbon footprints but are less biodegradable or more noxious -- yet are more attractive in other ways.



While crop biotechnology may provide a more productive, varied, and stable feedstock platform for a biofuels industry, the potential for early conflict with food is probably underestimated. The role of byproducts such as DDGS, and possibly biodiesel glycerine, in balancing animal nutrition supplies is conversely underrated or even missed by many analysts.



Nonetheless, the market's mere perception of competition of biofuels for sugar and grains with the food, feed, and fibers sectors seems to be enough to cause dislocations. This is already evident in the markedly higher late 2006 prices for U.S. corn, Brazilian sugarcane, and European rapeseed -- each the primary biofuel feedstock in its venue.



The study outlines a number of highly attractive "paths of least resistance" for developing the global biofuels industry based on leveraging current or co-developing technologies, such as coal gasification and gas-to-liquids catalysis.
For the interim strategy of fermenting sugars from biomass, a number of preparation options are available, and thermal utilization of fermentation process residues needs to be carefully considered. For the thermochemical platform of the future, more work must be done to develop in-field pyrolysis of biomass to help overcome logistics challenges, as well as biomass gasification and system optimization.



The study profiles a broad range of agricultural and biotechnology platforms and issues, and its geographic coverage includes the countries playing significant roles in biofuel feeds, production, and/or technology development over the next decade, including:


  • The Americas -- primarily, the U.S., Brazil, and Canada, and also other countries in the hemisphere with activities in liquid biofuels


  • Europe -- Western, Central, and Eastern, and Russia


  • Asia -- primarily, China, Japan, India, Thailand, and Malaysia, and also other countries in Asia with activities in liquid biofuels


  • Africa (primarily South Africa) and Australia.



    Additional information is availablae by e-mailing Ronald Cascone at rcascone@nexant.com or Heidi Junker Coleman at hcoleman@nexant.com.



    Nexant's products and services help clients solve critical strategic and operational challenges in several key areas: chemicals and petrochemicals, oil and gas, electric power, energy management, energy technology, retail and wholesale power markets, and enterprise risk management. The company is headquartered in San Francisco, Calif., and maintains offices in London, U.K.; Bangkok, Thailand; Tokyo, Japan; Beijing, China; Seoul, South Korea; White Plains, NY; Washington, D.C.; Houston, TX; Madison, WI; Boulder, CO; Salt Lake City, UT; Phoenix, AZ; and Los Angeles, CA. The company is owned by a select group of investors and Nexant management and employees.



    SOURCE: Nexant Inc. news release.