U.S. farm bill may halt Brazil cotton retaliation...for now
A new U.S. farm bill that reduces subsidies for cotton growers may stop Brazil from immediately slapping $830 million in trade sanctions on Washington.
A final solution to the decade-old dispute remains elusive, however, and Brazilian retaliation is still possible if the two countries' disagreements are not resolved over time, business groups and consultants from both countries told Reuters.
The U.S. Senate's approval on Tuesday of the farm bill was supposed to end the trade row, easing political and trade tension between the hemisphere's two biggest countries. Ties worsened in late 2013 over revelations Washington spied on President Dilma Rousseff's communications.
The bill, though, fails to meet all of the demands from Brazilian cotton producers and creates a new insurance scheme for U.S. growers, which some fear may push down prices in much the same way as the subsidies did.
"This is like a Brazilian soap opera, with every new episode, things get more complicated," said Diego Bonomo, executive manager of foreign trade with Brazil's Confederation of Industries, adding that the U.S. bill had gone some way in breaking this pattern.
"This is a step in the right direction, but we still don't have a definitive solution," said Bonomo.
Brazil won a challenge against U.S. cotton subsidies at the World Trade Organization in 2004 giving it the right to impose $830 million in sanctions against U.S. products. Brazil agreed to suspend the penalty if the United States paid into an assistance fund for Brazilian cotton farmers.
That agreement, under which the United States paid Brazil $147 million a year since 2010, was supposed to last until Washington passed farm legislation eliminating U.S. cotton subsidies.
The United States stopped paying the monthly compensation in October over budget disagreements in Congress, prompting the Brazilian government to prepare for retaliation that could come as early as March.
The farm bill, which is expected to be signed by President Barack Obama this week, eliminates subsidies on cotton production and grants the U.S. Agriculture Department powers to negotiate with Brazilian authorities changes to export loans known as export-credit guarantees.
The new crop insurance program is an important step toward a final resolution of the long-standing case, the National Cotton Council of America's chairman Jimmy Dodson said in a statement earlier this week.
Even so, critics say the creation of the insurance, which would almost entirely cover any losses for U.S. cotton farmers, could scuttle a deal.
- Soy, cotton futures led the ag markets Wednesday morning
- Monthly fertilizer prices: Comparing 2014 through 2009
- USDA releases April water supply forecast for the West
- Know your enemy: The importance of weed identification
- Most Texas farmers have corn in the ground
- Mosaic to acquire ADM's Brazil, Paraguay fertilizer business
- Commentary: Blame anti-GMO groups for deaths
- Julie Borlaug says biotech is necessary in fight against hunger
- What does “sustainable” food and agriculture really mean?
- Climate change will reduce crop yields sooner than we thought
- Ohio bill to require certification to apply fertilizer
- Carbon-dioxide hurts nitrogen assimilation by plants